Donner Party: Lessons learned |

Donner Party: Lessons learned

There were nearly 90 members in the Donner Company and 81 of them were trapped by snow at Donner Lake and Alder Creek during the winter of 1846-47. Nearly half of the pioneers died before it was all over. Although the event occurred 160 years ago, it is still a heart-rending story; yet it helps us to understand how people cope with severe hardship and seemingly insurmountable challenges.

The tragic lesson was not lost on Californias pre-gold rush civilian population or on its interim government. Two years later, when early winter storms battered the Sierra high country in October and November of 1849, the first year of the gold rush, Californias military governor, Major General Persifer F. Smith, authorized $100,000 in emergency funding to finance relief teams for emigrants struggling along the Truckee and Carson trails, as well as the Lassen cutoff to the north. Governor Smith was less concerned with starvation as most emigrants had sufficient provisions to reach California, but due to the huge numbers of people on the trail that year, some would inevitably need food and general assistance.The main focus was on the lack of forage for the oxen and cattle that pulled the wagons. If wagons had to be abandoned, it might back up the stream of emigrants trying to reach California before snow closed the pass for the season. Teams of hired civilians and military personnel were sent eastward with water and fresh livestock to strategic locations near the mountains and in the desert of present-day western Nevada to assist people trying to cross the Sierra into California.Similar operations were conducted in 1850 and 1852, when large numbers of gold-seekers and inexperienced overland emigrants were entering the new state. Never again would a wagon company be stranded in the high country without food or help.

After traveling the California Trail in 1846, T.H. Jefferson published a detailed trail map of the route in 1849. Historian Dale Morgan considered it one of the great American maps, an extraordinarily original production which will always have a special place in the cartography of the West.This Map of the Emigrant Road from Independence, Mo., to St. Francisco, California, was sold in New York City for the stiff price of $3 a copy. The map, with its printed Accompaniment of eleven pages, was published early enough in the year that at least one forty-niner, J. Goldsborough Bruff, carried a copy overland. Included in the Accompaniment text is the following advice, no doubt inspired by the Donner party tragedy: The most difficult portion of the whole journey is the passage of the Californian Mountains, and particularly the descent of the western side. The only serious difficulty, however, is when you arrive late in the season, with a short supply of bread stuff, and encounter snow ten or fifteen feet deep. Those who expect to cross in safety must reach the Truckee [Donner] Pass by the 1st of October. The snow does not usually begin falling till November, and remains upon the ground more or less till May. If you arrive late, however, and encounter snow, do not attempt to cross the mountain, but scatter at once into small parties and retreat to the eastern base of the mountains [Truckee Meadows], where you will find fertile valleys free from snow, which afford game, salmon, and roots, enough for small parties. You can winter there, and cross at the Truckee Pass when the snow is gone.

The mortality rates among the members of the Donner party represent the physiological and sociological differences between men and women, the strength of family groups and the age factor. In the Donner tragedy, females survived better than the males. Of the 36 who perished in the mountains, 27 were men and nine were women. In the Forlorn Hope snowshoe party of 15 people, eight men died; two men and all five women survived the long trek to safety. One of the reasons is that females are longer-lived than males and suffer less mortality across all age classes. Women also have less muscle mass and a higher percentage of body fat (roughly 27 percent compared to about 15 percent in males). The fat is distributed in a larger proportion subcutaneously, which makes it an effective insulator. Two thirds of the men died, while two thirds of the women survived.According to Donner party research conducted by archaeologist Donald Grayson of the University of Washington, women are twice as likely as men to survive extreme cold and hunger; more body fat, a lower metabolic rate and a temperament that is less prone to aggression make women the hardier sex when it comes to surviving this kind of disaster. Of the 30 males who died, 13.3 percent died as a result of violence, but there is no convincing evidence that any female member died violently. Family groups were important: All of the adult males who survived the entrapment (Breen, Eddy, Foster and Keseberg) were fathers. Every one of the single bachelors over the age of 21 died. Of the children under the age of five, 62.5 percent died; no adults over the age of 49 survived, except for Patrick Breen who was 51. The highest rate of survival was among children ages 6 through 14 of the 21 in that group, only two died.

One cause for the inordinate number of male deaths is likely the result of role expectations. Almost exclusively, the men were responsible for cutting trees and breaking branches, gathering firewood, locating food, driving oxen and cattle, moving snow, repairing and sharpening large items and building shelters, along with other typically male duties. Once they were snowbound in the mountains, these predominantly outdoor activities exposed the men to wet weather and cold temperatures, which contributed to evaporative heat loss and sapped their energy. Many of the adult men paid the ultimate price for their sacrifice to the group; only 27 percent of them survived, while 67 percent of the adult women and 87 percent of the adolescents lived. Its due to the courage, sacrifice and perseverance of the adult members of this pioneer party and their rescuers that nearly 90 percent of all the children survived to reach California.Mark McLaughlin’s column, “Weather Window,” appears every other week in the Sierra Sun. He is a nationally published writer and photographer whose award-winning books, “The Donner Party: Weathering the Storm,” “Sierra Stories: True Tales of Tahoe, Vol. 1 & 2,” and “Western Train Adventures: The Good, the Bad & the Ugly” are available at local stores. Mark, a Carnelian Bay resident, can be reached at

Support Local Journalism


Support Local Journalism

Readers around Lake Tahoe, Truckee, and beyond make the Sierra Sun's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.

Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User