Ted Gaines: Gov. Newsom plays Robin Hood with rebate
California actually has a government spending limit, hard as that may be to believe, and Gov. Gavin Newsom is making a mockery of it, just as his predecessor did.
In 1979, a year after signing off on the revolutionary Proposition 13, voters passed Proposition 4, implementing the Gann Limit, which would peg California’s state spending to the 1978-79 level and only let it grow adjusted for inflation and population. State revenues above the voter-approved limit can be reckoned with several ways, including refunding half of the excess revenues to taxpayers, with the other half going to schools.
Newsom is choosing the refund path for this year’s massive Gann Limit excess, currently estimated at $16 billion. But instead of sending their money back to the taxpayers in relation to how much they paid, giving everyone a slice of the rebate in proportion to their tax contributions, Newsom is turning the program into a giant transfer payment scheme.
Paul Gann, the father of Prop. 13 and the namesake of this taxpayer protection plan, would be dumbfounded by Newsom’s willful misunderstanding and shameless appropriation of his taxpayer-protection initiative.
The wealthiest taxpayers in this state, the top 5%, paid nearly 70% of California income taxes last year. Those citizens were also supposed to get relief from the Gann Limit. Instead, they get nothing.
Newsom is sending rebates to the bottom two-thirds of tax filers only. What about the top-third, who paid a whopping 97% of the total income taxes in 2018, for example? In Newsom’s redistribution plan, these top payers are simply out of luck, even though it’s their payments providing the bulk of the excess.
Before you shout, “Tax the rich!” understand that in that same tax year, we are talking about people making $60,000 a year.
It’s great that the governor wants to help taxpayers during the pandemic, even though it was state policy that caused so much of the damage to small businesses and killed so many jobs. If the governor and Legislature want to make more direct payments to citizens out of the general fund, after Gann Limit refunds have been fairly distributed, be my guest.
In fact, I challenge Newsom and the Legislature to find ways to make the state more affordable and livable for all citizens, starting with lower taxes on personal income, on business income, on gasoline, and by eliminating green energy mandates that have forced our electricity prices up nine times faster than the national average over the past decade. These steps would help every day of the year, not just on the day he announces his budget.
Getting money back into the hands of job-creators — by lowering costs and equitably rebating the Gann Limit dollars — would actually fuel a California rebound.
But to repurpose a taxpayer protection act approved by voters into a new tax and welfare plan is bad-faith politics and speaks to why Newsom is facing a recall.
Gov. Brown’s 2017 budget dodged the Gann Limit by magically reclassifying $22 billion in spending as neither state nor local, as required by the original proposition, making it disappear along with the hopes of fiscal conservatives.
Brown would not adhere to the mandates of the 1979 Gann Limit reform. He tricked his way past the law and shafted taxpayers along the way.
Apparently, Newsom was watching and learning, waiting for his own opportunity to betray the intent of California’s voters.
Newsom’s plan is ugly political alchemy in which he mutates a rebate program into a new tax on the homeowners, small-business owners, teachers, police and other middle-class people who will be paying taxes they will never get back. He should refund all taxpayers according to their tax payments and quit manipulating the Gann Limit for his political needs.
Former state Sen. Ted Gaines represents the Board of Equalization’s First District with nearly 10 million constituents in 30 counties of northern, eastern and southern California. For more information, visit boe.ca.gov/Gaines.
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around Lake Tahoe, Truckee, and beyond make the Sierra Sun's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User