Opinion: Will Placer County ignore residents regarding Martis Valley West? | SierraSun.com

Opinion: Will Placer County ignore residents regarding Martis Valley West?

It was a full house … around 250 people attended the Placer County Planning Commission meeting at Granlibakken Tahoe on June 9.

Placer County staff requested approval of the contentious Martis Valley West project, which consists of a gated community of 760 units (1,900 new folks at least) and 6 acres of commercial plopped in the forest on top of SR 267.

Never mind that the Truckee Tahoe Airport, Tahoe Area Sierra Club, Mountain Area Preservation, North Tahoe Preservation Alliance, Friends of the West Shore, Sierra Watch and the League to Save Lake Tahoe all requested denial of the project.

Forty members of the public spoke, but only two said they were in favor: the wife of the developer and Eugene Roeder who is a member of the North Tahoe Regional Municipal Advisory Council. Additionally, over 5,000 petition signatures have been collected and delivered, requesting no Tahoe basin or ridgeline development.

To paraphrase:

The meeting lasted 6.5 hours, yet around 100 passionate Tahoe lovers stuck it out the entire time. Yes, it was painful especially when the developer’s attorney and other representatives had the final word after public testimony.

The spin narrative was continued and they failed to answer the Planning Commission’s legitimate concerns: Oh no sir, you won’t see Lake Tahoe from 75-foot-tall condominiums on the Tahoe basin boundary line.

Right commissioner, we won’t build affordable housing on site, we’d rather contribute money into a fund to build it somewhere else.

The project site isn’t appropriate for affordable housing. Absolutely, we will pay into a fund to add two more lanes on SR 267 that is currently inadequately funded. No worries sirs, there is a plan to evacuate the east side of Placer County … everyone leaves on SR 267.

Once again the developer, Mountainside Partners, formerly East/West Partners, downplayed its current additive application for the 550-space adjacent “Brockway Campground.” Which, when you add the 550 spaces (870,000 square feet of soil disturbance) to the 760 units (11 million sq. ft. of disturbance) there really is no reduction in potential development.

June 9 was a red flag day for fire danger, and conspicuously absent at the meeting were representatives of the fire departments. The evacuation study by LSC claims 1.3 to 1.5 hours to evacuate the project in case of fire; however the document doesn’t consider in the mix if Kings Beach and Incline Village have to evacuate at the same time.

The questionable emergency preparedness study done by Mountainside Partners also claims everyone evacuating will be directed by their staff turn left from the project toward Truckee. Their staff will have to be extremely brave souls. The emergency preparedness study by Mountainside Partners assumes just one fire scenario and doesn’t consider a wind-driven event, which makes their plan useless.

At the end of the hearing, the commission elected to delay approval until they could have a hearing attended by Caltrans, U.S. Forest Service and the North Tahoe and Northstar fire districts.

They considered not allowing public comment. Wow. Larry Sevison, commissioner, tried to orchestrate an approval anyway which deferred the issues of fire evacuation and traffic congestion until later subsequent project approvals.

Luckily for Lake Tahoe/Truckee, that idea didn’t succeed. These significant environmental impacts must be sorted out now.

By the way, Mountainside Partners claims it won’t consider a smaller project. They must build 760 units or the project won’t be financially feasible due to high infrastructure costs.

Hmmm, maybe the project concept of building in the middle of the forest on a ridge far from any existing development or infrastructure is a bad idea. What do you think? There’s a concept for you.

Write your Gov. Jerry Brown-maybe he’ll listen if Placer County won’t:

Subject: Martis Valley West Project

Governor Jerry Brown

c/o State Capitol, Suite 1173

Sacramento, CA 95814

Phone: (916) 445-2841

Fax: (916) 558-3160

Email: https://govnews.ca.gov/gov39mail/webmail.php

Dear Governor Brown — tell Placer County they represent their citizens, not Martis Valley West developers.

Ann Nichols is a 39-year North Lake Tahoe resident and is president of the North Tahoe Preservation Alliance. Visit http://www.ntpac.com to learn more.

Support Local Journalism


Support Local Journalism

Readers around Lake Tahoe, Truckee, and beyond make the Sierra Sun's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.

Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User


Jeff Collins: Kudos to CHP, North Tahoe Fire


Thanks and kudos to the CHP and North Tahoe Fire Protection District for quick response in exterminating a garbage truck fire last Friday. CHP Officer Graham spotted the smoke, notified the TTSD driver and immediately…

See more